Pharmacy is about drug delivery/outcomes. When there are no drugs, the clinical pharmacist or any pharmacist for that matter finds no use for his skills. Let the pharmacists take over everything about drugs-including being the main signatories for all funds available for purchase of drugs. A professional is that who can make decisions and/or solve problems. Let the pharmacists solve drugs supply, drug use, drug misuse, drugs abuse, drug underuse and drug overuse problems. You cant put to task a pharmacist for what they he (sorry for the use of one gender) is not responsible for in his performance appraisal-he is not responsible for the perennial stock outs! In the same breath you cant squeeze the juice out of somebody's profession, curtail his job satisfaction and and go ahead and expect him to deliver. It consummately baffles me when the system lets someone who is not a pharmacist take over the most pleasant, most innovative, most outstanding and most progressive part of my job, and leaves me to do the most mechanical and repetitive (read boring) part of the job; a part that does not give me the chance to grow and take more responsibility before my retirement.
This meeting is very timely and the record needs to be set straight. The 'local arrangement' management of the public sector where one person is everything has to stop. Everything we do from now henceforth has to be supported by the law. If the law as it is has in any way derailed or has attempted to derail and threatened the survival of the pharmacy profession, then we must act and fast. We must not engage without putting conditions. We have to tell them what needs to be done, or ask them to stop training pharmacists altogether. No office must curtail and abruptly bring to an end to the dreams of any Kenyan child. Even more importantly, no individual should ever be allowed to have such powers.
On that score, this is the most irresponsible, most corrupted and and the most confused health system that has ever been in the world.
Everyone wants to play your role, qualifications notwithstanding, when there is money and blame you for their mess when the money runs out or where there is no money.
Please allow those pharmacists who are still in public sector to have something to do and be happy about, or the average age for those who can still stomach those issues will always be below 30. Need I say that pharmacists in public sector are all young and 'inexperienced', and that this will go on for as long as there is nothing to do 'for pharmacy' there? Who wants to grow old in such a system?
That meeting, I will attend; not for me, but for others who need me. I would want to return to the public sector as a 'Director' or as a PS, not as a spineless 'Chief' who cannot even be allowed to manage his own secretary by a guy who makes up for his lack of eloquence with hate and tyranny.
If the way forward of that meeting does not tackle the autonomy and clear career progression of pharmacists; one that will make an individual pharmacist plan his career life by saying 'I will go back to school, to do this so that I become this...et cetera et cetera'..., then we are doing nothing. We must say if we are not able to achieve to this end over a certain time-frame, then lets all resign from this job with false sense of security, we venture out there together and take over the pharmaceutical economy, because even that we have let others to. Then we start managing all drug issues, in all pharmacy specialties and sub-specialties that we will define, and in our own terms. Who said pharmacists can only achieve the health ministry goals by remaining as their employees? So long as we keep a few in the critical areas and pray to God; and pray really hard that they stop being part of the problem that is already undermining them anyway, then we are set. I hope they see that point and realize that the day pharmacists are empowered, they too will gain but ten-fold, and PPB might just become the most powerful institution in the health or even the larger social sector. Somebody needs to open their eyes, and take them back to the day they decided as a high school graduates to pursue pharmacy. That nostalgic feeling has to come back. They should be allowed to take their minds through on wild journey of the reason they were born.
So what is this thing that pharmacists can do in their own right without reference to anybody else? Everything. Did you know that the only way you can shape legislative process is by being a strong and visible lobby group and with money to boot? Our lawmakers can only debate on your issues when they are pampered and taken for some luxurious retreat somewhere, at your cost
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
A new post on Pharmacy solutions blog
The excerpts are...
....Now Kenya usually has two rules-the one on paper and the one that carries the day. Pharmacists are the only health professionals who zealously protect what is on paper; the 8-5pm working hours rule, and as it goes, it takes a pharmacist to enforce this work ethic among the other pharmacists.....
....I do not know if there is a pharmacy version of open professional ‘rebellion’ that is only good to the pharmacists and is protected to death by our bosses. In short, our work is quantitative and not qualitative. We are not allowed to make ‘extra money’ on the side lest we lose focus on the ‘very important job’ we were employed for. This is a very good rule, but look where it has taken us?
No wonder everyone is going public health.
Check it out on http://timkopussolutions.blogspot.com/ and send in your comments
....Now Kenya usually has two rules-the one on paper and the one that carries the day. Pharmacists are the only health professionals who zealously protect what is on paper; the 8-5pm working hours rule, and as it goes, it takes a pharmacist to enforce this work ethic among the other pharmacists.....
....I do not know if there is a pharmacy version of open professional ‘rebellion’ that is only good to the pharmacists and is protected to death by our bosses. In short, our work is quantitative and not qualitative. We are not allowed to make ‘extra money’ on the side lest we lose focus on the ‘very important job’ we were employed for. This is a very good rule, but look where it has taken us?
No wonder everyone is going public health.
Check it out on http://timkopussolutions.blogspot.com/ and send in your comments
Sunday, May 3, 2009
What I want to take to the floor of the PSK sympossium
PSK annual scientific conferences and/or symposia have recently attracted increasing attention of the Pharmacists at the policy making levels in the Pharmacy and Poisons Board (PPB) unlike in the past. Together with the increase in subscription membership to the PSK that has been achieved due to cooperation by PPB in issuing licenses only to Pharmacists who participate in Continuous Professional Development (CPD), PSK have become a soft and probably effective pressure on the Authorities to institute desired changes and attitudes among the Pharmacists.
A symposium of such a stature cannot be successful without the participation of Pharmacists who have less than 10 years experience post registration, the ones I will call young. The kinds who have fresh ideas and motivation to pursue the value addition practice, a pharmacy service that has become elusive for the several decade old profession in Kenya. These are the pharmacists who see themselves practicing in the next 20 years or more in the only trade that they know and have everything to gain from implementation of the new National Pharmacy Policy. Of course that will only be possible if the policy makers consult widely and make policies in the interest of the pharmacy profession.
Unfortunately this group of young pharmacists, who have seen non-professional competition too many, and whose future is in grievous danger, do not have resources that participation in such forums demand. It is however noteworthy that some of the pharmacists in the public sector and especially those at the PPB, the National Quality Control Laboratories (NQCL), and Government Chemist successfully get backing from their pharmacists led departments to make their contribution in such forums. Those working for the programmes may also be able to secure the support of their non-pharmacists directors because of the close working relationships among the lean staff and availability of funds for travel activities in the programmes. The mainstream civil service is a sea of push and shove and professional rivalries stand in the way of ambitious pharmacists in the sector and so it would be difficult for the hospitals to devote their precious travel and accommodation cost sharing funds for the benefit of pharmacist, even for only once every two years.
The pharmacists in the private sector may or may not be able to secure such sponsorships from their employers if it was not negotiated as part of their contracts. It might be now important for me to point out to those young pharmacists who will want to seek greener pastures that they should talk about professional development as part of the employment benefits. Professional development includes sponsorships to PSK scientific conferences. Those in private hospitals also depend on the benevolence of their administrators, and may sometimes not participate in the annual symposia because of work constraints, and not necessarily lack of funds, either private or employer provided. This leaves such forums to older pharmacists who may have made substantial investment outside pharmacy and do not put so much stakes in the improvement of pharmacy professional environment.
The branding of pharmacy concept that I had helped develop in my PSK branch must find itself in the floor of the hospital and community sector sessions. The branding concept allows for an interim measure of collaboration with lower tier pharmaceutical professionals who have been enrolled and are members of the Kenya Pharmaceutical Association (KPA) to fill the gaps that have been exploited by quacks for far too long. The branding will recognize these two groups of professionals who are recognised by the law effective from the year 2000 or so. The signatories of the branding concept in PSK and KPA must however accept to allow the branding concept to make a clear differentiation between a registered and licensed pharmacist and a pharmaceutical technologist by use of colour codes. Some of the suggestions are green colour theme for pharmacist run pharmacies and blue colour theme for pharmaceutical technologists run pharmacies. The onus will then be on the pharmacists to acquire new skills that will clearly them in the leadership position and be associated with quality.
The pharmacist must be seen to add value to the current practice and all over the world this has been through more patients and health care providers’ information. It is also a good practice to select and carry out medication use reviews (MURs) of, may be, ten or more prescriptions or a day. The concept started in UK, allows a pharmacist to intentionally go into much more detail of the select patients’ condition, biodata and treatments prescribed and advice on the medication as well as related lifestyle changes or preventive or prophylactic measures that may fit for the individual patient. It may even require contacting the patient’s doctor, this time not to request for prescription changes, but to show concern on the general health of the patient. MUR data is then documented by the pharmacist for the sake of follow up and/or learning. MURs are known to take up to four times longer than the normal prescription filling time, and may jeopardize the revenues in a busy pharmacy. They however guarantee more long term benefits to the pharmacies that have made it part of the work requirements because the image that the patient gets is that of a professional and not just a businessman. Such measures may need the superintendent pharmacists discuss with their employers or partners to achieve wider acceptance and to justify for the additional costs that such a measure may put on the business when an additional staff member may need to be hired.
PHARMACY BRANDING: IS IT ACHIEVABLE? WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS?
Yes it is achievable; and now more than before very necessary. The regulation of community pharmacy practice in Kenya poses great challenges to the relevant authorities. Remember private hospital pharmacies must also meet the same licencing requirements as the community pharmacies. This is due to the proliferation of unauthorized drug outlets all over the country manned by untrained and unscrupulous individuals. A survey by the pharmacy and poisons board in 2006 showed that there are over 15,000 outlets of which only about 3000 are licensed.
The PPB has in the few years tried various intervention measures but has borne no fruits so far.
These include inter alia:
a) Annual licensing of pharmacies and use of professional bodies to vet the licensees i.e. PSK and KPA.
b) Increasing the number of officers and professionalizing the drug inspectorate.
Despite the measures, Kenyans still access most of their medications from individuals who cannot bear any professional responsibility whatsoever. Part of these is the issuing of licenses by culpable PPB officials or low cadre and poorly remunerated drug inspectors who find fortune in the discipline of endangering patients’ lives and betray the same cause in which they were hired for. Unfair competition to qualified persons and the defeat of the purpose of years of pharmaceutical training, registration and annual licensing at a huge cost to the professional is just but one of the effects of this. Other more grievous effects are a wide open window for drugs abuse and misuse and incredible endangering of patient’s life.
Branding is not a new concept in the world of business and it thrives on giving a certain product unmistakable identity. This has worked out very well for the clients of banks, petroleum companies, telephony service providers and retail shops like Bata Shoe Company and Nakumatt and Uchumi supermarkets. This is what I propose to be done in all outlets run by professionals and has the physical presence of the professional or hired professional locum pharmacists at all times.
A brand allows us, the pharmacists and the stakeholders to police ourselves, with little regard to who gets phony licenses or is allowed to practice by the PPB. The distinct symbols, emblems and insignia are then widely advertised and publicized in all the PSK forums and KPA can then choose to fund their own publicity campaigns. In other words, it frees the drug inspectors from the responsibilities of allowing who remains open or not and rightfully transfers that responsibility to the sensitized and well informed public. The brand is then registered as a trademark and the users are then protected from infringement by unwelcome elements by making such act a criminal offence. Such individuals will be prosecuted by the State as criminals. The pooled subscriptions by members can then provide substantial resources to support legal proceedings against such offenders, with the support of the government.
THE BRANDING PROCESS
The principle behind the branding process should be sold to both PSK and KPA. This will involve the following activities:
i. Establishment of a PSK/KPA Joint task force
Upon approval by the PSK Council, the largest decision making organ in PSK, the national chairman will initiate the process of appointment of a joint task force with KPA which will implement the concept.
ii. Identification of brand mark
The task force seeks out for sponsorship of the exercise. The activities will include the advertisement to paid-up members and to the associate members like pharmacy students for suitable designs and offer cash awards for the winning designs. That includes the 1st runners up and the 2nd runners up. The participant will also be issued with a certificate of participation in or contribution to the development of suitable design of the pharmacy brand.
iii. Registration of the approved design
The winning design is presented to the PPB, which as a body corporate can register the emblem with the relevant government body and then publish it in the Kenya Gazette. This will make it a legal entity for use in all outlets approved by the Board.
iv. Branding of outlets
The branding costs can be shouldered by the individual pharmacies or a sponsor is sought to contract the services of a firm that can make unique branding that must only be done to members. An allowance can be made for individual pharmacies to have their own identity but must embrace the new mark of quality. A mix of the two can be achieved with much consultation.
v. Aggressive print and electronic media publicity campaign
It will most likely be a two tier process, with contribution of a sponsoring pharmacy advocacy initiative and the stakeholder pharmacies. All information sources to the public are flooded with the insistence on only obtaining medications from the branded pharmacies. This will include the use of radio, television, print media (newspapers and niche magazines), internet, billboards, road shows and other modes of public information for the benefit of the pharmacists run pharmacies. This is the point where the two cadres solicit for their own support as permitted by the law.
vi. PSK policing of pharmacies
This is to ensure that the brand does not end up at the doors of a mark of quality pharmacy. The professional manning the facility will be expected to exceed the ethical and professional expectations expected of a registered pharmacist. The pharmacy must never be left to be under the control of any lesser individual. The patient will then have a right to complain to the PSK about the quality of service of a pharmacist through the toll free number that will be available within the premises.
CHALLENGES TO THE OPERATIONALISATION OF SUCH BRAND
UNSCRUPULOUS PHARMACISTS
It is well known that some of the quacks that have infiltrated the pharmacy practice thrive because of support by unethical pharmacists. A system that allows the acceptance of the photocopied credentials of a pharmacist prominently displayed for all to see, mean nothing if the individual offering the service is not that pharmacist or equally competent employee of the pharmacist. It is a fact that a copy of academic and professional certificates given to the benevolence of a quack does not photocopy the acquired knowledge, skills and attitudes of the real owner of the certificates. But how can we handle such a situation for pharmacists who have made this habit a way of life and a source of easy income? That will clearly continue to be a challenge because the resistance will come from the ‘quack reincarnate’, the pharmacist who has put selfish, short-term, personal matters before the profession. This will be addresses by an effective PSK policing
INCREASED PHARMACISTS DEMAND
There may be increased demand for qualified personnel that might not be satisfied by the training of new entry level pharmacists and pharmaceutical technologists for this matter. If this demand is not met, then the quackery system may rear its head again. This will be partially mitigated by the involvement of pharmaceutical technologists for more reach, especially in rural areas.
UNCOOPERATIVE PPB
There might be resistance by some elements in the PPB who thrive in the chaotic state of Community Pharmacy practice. The PSK as an influential institution with four of its members being appointed to the Board every three years should be able to overcome such hurdles in the long term. The change agents can then be rewarded by their terms of service being extended at the expiry of three years.
DISPENSING DOCTORS
It is now a growing trend among the doctors in private practice to have fully fledged pharmacies in their clinics and surgeries in Kenya without the pain of seeking and paying for the licence costs at the PPB. We all know that it is illegal but it seems that no law enforcement agency is acting like it would if a pharmacist opened a clinic. The reasons are varied with some just being plain ignorance of what is happening by the PPB and the police. Such doctor will continue to threaten the brand concept because the design of their clinics and surgeries is in such a way that the patients are cajoled to buy medications that are sold at unusually high margins, sometimes almost 100% of the trade price. Such doctors have been reported also to direct patients to buy drugs from non-pharmacists run pharmacies betraying the professional referral systems expected of a doctor.
CONCLUSION
It is my hope and belief that this concept will be given serious consideration. PPB alone cannot effectively enforce the law. A well informed public will give us the best support than we have ever imagined. I’m yet to find a human being who does not go for the best service possible if they know where and from whom to get that service. Take up the challenge and use it.
A symposium of such a stature cannot be successful without the participation of Pharmacists who have less than 10 years experience post registration, the ones I will call young. The kinds who have fresh ideas and motivation to pursue the value addition practice, a pharmacy service that has become elusive for the several decade old profession in Kenya. These are the pharmacists who see themselves practicing in the next 20 years or more in the only trade that they know and have everything to gain from implementation of the new National Pharmacy Policy. Of course that will only be possible if the policy makers consult widely and make policies in the interest of the pharmacy profession.
Unfortunately this group of young pharmacists, who have seen non-professional competition too many, and whose future is in grievous danger, do not have resources that participation in such forums demand. It is however noteworthy that some of the pharmacists in the public sector and especially those at the PPB, the National Quality Control Laboratories (NQCL), and Government Chemist successfully get backing from their pharmacists led departments to make their contribution in such forums. Those working for the programmes may also be able to secure the support of their non-pharmacists directors because of the close working relationships among the lean staff and availability of funds for travel activities in the programmes. The mainstream civil service is a sea of push and shove and professional rivalries stand in the way of ambitious pharmacists in the sector and so it would be difficult for the hospitals to devote their precious travel and accommodation cost sharing funds for the benefit of pharmacist, even for only once every two years.
The pharmacists in the private sector may or may not be able to secure such sponsorships from their employers if it was not negotiated as part of their contracts. It might be now important for me to point out to those young pharmacists who will want to seek greener pastures that they should talk about professional development as part of the employment benefits. Professional development includes sponsorships to PSK scientific conferences. Those in private hospitals also depend on the benevolence of their administrators, and may sometimes not participate in the annual symposia because of work constraints, and not necessarily lack of funds, either private or employer provided. This leaves such forums to older pharmacists who may have made substantial investment outside pharmacy and do not put so much stakes in the improvement of pharmacy professional environment.
The branding of pharmacy concept that I had helped develop in my PSK branch must find itself in the floor of the hospital and community sector sessions. The branding concept allows for an interim measure of collaboration with lower tier pharmaceutical professionals who have been enrolled and are members of the Kenya Pharmaceutical Association (KPA) to fill the gaps that have been exploited by quacks for far too long. The branding will recognize these two groups of professionals who are recognised by the law effective from the year 2000 or so. The signatories of the branding concept in PSK and KPA must however accept to allow the branding concept to make a clear differentiation between a registered and licensed pharmacist and a pharmaceutical technologist by use of colour codes. Some of the suggestions are green colour theme for pharmacist run pharmacies and blue colour theme for pharmaceutical technologists run pharmacies. The onus will then be on the pharmacists to acquire new skills that will clearly them in the leadership position and be associated with quality.
The pharmacist must be seen to add value to the current practice and all over the world this has been through more patients and health care providers’ information. It is also a good practice to select and carry out medication use reviews (MURs) of, may be, ten or more prescriptions or a day. The concept started in UK, allows a pharmacist to intentionally go into much more detail of the select patients’ condition, biodata and treatments prescribed and advice on the medication as well as related lifestyle changes or preventive or prophylactic measures that may fit for the individual patient. It may even require contacting the patient’s doctor, this time not to request for prescription changes, but to show concern on the general health of the patient. MUR data is then documented by the pharmacist for the sake of follow up and/or learning. MURs are known to take up to four times longer than the normal prescription filling time, and may jeopardize the revenues in a busy pharmacy. They however guarantee more long term benefits to the pharmacies that have made it part of the work requirements because the image that the patient gets is that of a professional and not just a businessman. Such measures may need the superintendent pharmacists discuss with their employers or partners to achieve wider acceptance and to justify for the additional costs that such a measure may put on the business when an additional staff member may need to be hired.
PHARMACY BRANDING: IS IT ACHIEVABLE? WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS?
Yes it is achievable; and now more than before very necessary. The regulation of community pharmacy practice in Kenya poses great challenges to the relevant authorities. Remember private hospital pharmacies must also meet the same licencing requirements as the community pharmacies. This is due to the proliferation of unauthorized drug outlets all over the country manned by untrained and unscrupulous individuals. A survey by the pharmacy and poisons board in 2006 showed that there are over 15,000 outlets of which only about 3000 are licensed.
The PPB has in the few years tried various intervention measures but has borne no fruits so far.
These include inter alia:
a) Annual licensing of pharmacies and use of professional bodies to vet the licensees i.e. PSK and KPA.
b) Increasing the number of officers and professionalizing the drug inspectorate.
Despite the measures, Kenyans still access most of their medications from individuals who cannot bear any professional responsibility whatsoever. Part of these is the issuing of licenses by culpable PPB officials or low cadre and poorly remunerated drug inspectors who find fortune in the discipline of endangering patients’ lives and betray the same cause in which they were hired for. Unfair competition to qualified persons and the defeat of the purpose of years of pharmaceutical training, registration and annual licensing at a huge cost to the professional is just but one of the effects of this. Other more grievous effects are a wide open window for drugs abuse and misuse and incredible endangering of patient’s life.
Branding is not a new concept in the world of business and it thrives on giving a certain product unmistakable identity. This has worked out very well for the clients of banks, petroleum companies, telephony service providers and retail shops like Bata Shoe Company and Nakumatt and Uchumi supermarkets. This is what I propose to be done in all outlets run by professionals and has the physical presence of the professional or hired professional locum pharmacists at all times.
A brand allows us, the pharmacists and the stakeholders to police ourselves, with little regard to who gets phony licenses or is allowed to practice by the PPB. The distinct symbols, emblems and insignia are then widely advertised and publicized in all the PSK forums and KPA can then choose to fund their own publicity campaigns. In other words, it frees the drug inspectors from the responsibilities of allowing who remains open or not and rightfully transfers that responsibility to the sensitized and well informed public. The brand is then registered as a trademark and the users are then protected from infringement by unwelcome elements by making such act a criminal offence. Such individuals will be prosecuted by the State as criminals. The pooled subscriptions by members can then provide substantial resources to support legal proceedings against such offenders, with the support of the government.
THE BRANDING PROCESS
The principle behind the branding process should be sold to both PSK and KPA. This will involve the following activities:
i. Establishment of a PSK/KPA Joint task force
Upon approval by the PSK Council, the largest decision making organ in PSK, the national chairman will initiate the process of appointment of a joint task force with KPA which will implement the concept.
ii. Identification of brand mark
The task force seeks out for sponsorship of the exercise. The activities will include the advertisement to paid-up members and to the associate members like pharmacy students for suitable designs and offer cash awards for the winning designs. That includes the 1st runners up and the 2nd runners up. The participant will also be issued with a certificate of participation in or contribution to the development of suitable design of the pharmacy brand.
iii. Registration of the approved design
The winning design is presented to the PPB, which as a body corporate can register the emblem with the relevant government body and then publish it in the Kenya Gazette. This will make it a legal entity for use in all outlets approved by the Board.
iv. Branding of outlets
The branding costs can be shouldered by the individual pharmacies or a sponsor is sought to contract the services of a firm that can make unique branding that must only be done to members. An allowance can be made for individual pharmacies to have their own identity but must embrace the new mark of quality. A mix of the two can be achieved with much consultation.
v. Aggressive print and electronic media publicity campaign
It will most likely be a two tier process, with contribution of a sponsoring pharmacy advocacy initiative and the stakeholder pharmacies. All information sources to the public are flooded with the insistence on only obtaining medications from the branded pharmacies. This will include the use of radio, television, print media (newspapers and niche magazines), internet, billboards, road shows and other modes of public information for the benefit of the pharmacists run pharmacies. This is the point where the two cadres solicit for their own support as permitted by the law.
vi. PSK policing of pharmacies
This is to ensure that the brand does not end up at the doors of a mark of quality pharmacy. The professional manning the facility will be expected to exceed the ethical and professional expectations expected of a registered pharmacist. The pharmacy must never be left to be under the control of any lesser individual. The patient will then have a right to complain to the PSK about the quality of service of a pharmacist through the toll free number that will be available within the premises.
CHALLENGES TO THE OPERATIONALISATION OF SUCH BRAND
UNSCRUPULOUS PHARMACISTS
It is well known that some of the quacks that have infiltrated the pharmacy practice thrive because of support by unethical pharmacists. A system that allows the acceptance of the photocopied credentials of a pharmacist prominently displayed for all to see, mean nothing if the individual offering the service is not that pharmacist or equally competent employee of the pharmacist. It is a fact that a copy of academic and professional certificates given to the benevolence of a quack does not photocopy the acquired knowledge, skills and attitudes of the real owner of the certificates. But how can we handle such a situation for pharmacists who have made this habit a way of life and a source of easy income? That will clearly continue to be a challenge because the resistance will come from the ‘quack reincarnate’, the pharmacist who has put selfish, short-term, personal matters before the profession. This will be addresses by an effective PSK policing
INCREASED PHARMACISTS DEMAND
There may be increased demand for qualified personnel that might not be satisfied by the training of new entry level pharmacists and pharmaceutical technologists for this matter. If this demand is not met, then the quackery system may rear its head again. This will be partially mitigated by the involvement of pharmaceutical technologists for more reach, especially in rural areas.
UNCOOPERATIVE PPB
There might be resistance by some elements in the PPB who thrive in the chaotic state of Community Pharmacy practice. The PSK as an influential institution with four of its members being appointed to the Board every three years should be able to overcome such hurdles in the long term. The change agents can then be rewarded by their terms of service being extended at the expiry of three years.
DISPENSING DOCTORS
It is now a growing trend among the doctors in private practice to have fully fledged pharmacies in their clinics and surgeries in Kenya without the pain of seeking and paying for the licence costs at the PPB. We all know that it is illegal but it seems that no law enforcement agency is acting like it would if a pharmacist opened a clinic. The reasons are varied with some just being plain ignorance of what is happening by the PPB and the police. Such doctor will continue to threaten the brand concept because the design of their clinics and surgeries is in such a way that the patients are cajoled to buy medications that are sold at unusually high margins, sometimes almost 100% of the trade price. Such doctors have been reported also to direct patients to buy drugs from non-pharmacists run pharmacies betraying the professional referral systems expected of a doctor.
CONCLUSION
It is my hope and belief that this concept will be given serious consideration. PPB alone cannot effectively enforce the law. A well informed public will give us the best support than we have ever imagined. I’m yet to find a human being who does not go for the best service possible if they know where and from whom to get that service. Take up the challenge and use it.
Thursday, March 19, 2009
A very disappointing PPB!
If you trained in University of Nairobi, its time chest thumping stopped and we admit that our training did not meet the minimum competencies required for a pharmacist. If you dont agree with me, engage a randomn pharmacist on any issue you think is within the realmn of a pharmacist and you will see for yourself the results.
.................................................................................
Now that aside lets go to PPB issues, we are incompetent on the average, and thats not negotiable. I will expect DMS to fill in the gap that we created. I do not expect the Chief Pharmacist to even have an idea of what a cough syrup is, and the more reason why he must voluntarily relinquish his registrar post to PPB as we are awaiting for clarification to some contentious clauses in Pharmacy and Poisons Act of 2003. A vigilant pharmacist pointed out that that Act, which effectively repealed the older statute sneaked in a clause that the registrar shall be a Chief Pharmacist, (who is basically the administrator of public sector pharmacists and a technocrat in the parent ministry so many grades lower than the ministry's chief executive). No one knows if the clause was passed by the parliament or was sneaked in by the mover or was sneaked in at the printing stage effectively making it a typo error.
Someone please investigate, because it is that clause that brought in fundamental change in the operations of PPB and the overall management of the pharmaceutical sector. We have a Board that we elect representatives but have no control at all in its running. PSK elects/nominates 4 people for three years who absolutely have no control on what they were nominated to do.
The learning curve for pharmacists end with them being declared BPharm graduates.
There are no serious tutors who force pharmacist interns to put what they learnt in school (if any) into practice, worsening the already fragile situation. We do not have predecessors worth mentioning; the serious pharmacists are almost all under 35 and with less than 10yrs of experience and hardly possess anything much more than the first degree. Kenya is almost devoid of specialist pharmacists.
If we delinked PPB from the parent ministry, make it an Authority and give the Board the power to hire and fire its employees, there will be fundamental changes in Kenya pharmaceutical sector. The Board should not be staffed by the Ministry of Health employees, they should all be sent out to carry out service delivery. If I'm not competent to discharge regualtory functions with my current training and expereince, which I rank to be in the top quartile among the Kenyan pharmacists, no one in that Board has. Tell me one you believe is and I will give you a reward. Most of them are entry level pharmacists or even interns-what do they know? Regulatory activity is not about filling forms and dusting files and drinking tea, no. It is a well thought out process from an experienced specialist pharmacists who shoul dbe issuing weekly or monthly bulletins to be circulated to all stakeholders.
The Board members and the technical staff must have post graduate qualifications and have more than 10 years experience post registration, in all the represented areas in the Board's mandate unless they are secretaries (like the one who's upstairs and has issues in the upstairs) or accountants or sweepers or messengers or drivers or guards. The CEO must be selected in a competitive process. He must not be the sitting Chief Pharmacist. He must possess postgraduate qualifications in pharmacy as well as an advanced management degree because the Board draws a huge budget. He (and that also stands for she) must have excellent presentation skills and must have made significant contributions in the relevant publications. He must be compensated well and must not serve for more than two terms of four years each. He may serve in an advisory role for another four years if he successfully completes two-four year terms. Its only such a Board that can confirm or rubbish any drug claims and we listen.
As for now I will only trust my own independent research.
Without that, the DMS or the PS or the Minister or even the President can comment on the cough syrups. As things are now, they are all more competent than that Board, I'm sorry to say that.
.................................................................................
Now that aside lets go to PPB issues, we are incompetent on the average, and thats not negotiable. I will expect DMS to fill in the gap that we created. I do not expect the Chief Pharmacist to even have an idea of what a cough syrup is, and the more reason why he must voluntarily relinquish his registrar post to PPB as we are awaiting for clarification to some contentious clauses in Pharmacy and Poisons Act of 2003. A vigilant pharmacist pointed out that that Act, which effectively repealed the older statute sneaked in a clause that the registrar shall be a Chief Pharmacist, (who is basically the administrator of public sector pharmacists and a technocrat in the parent ministry so many grades lower than the ministry's chief executive). No one knows if the clause was passed by the parliament or was sneaked in by the mover or was sneaked in at the printing stage effectively making it a typo error.
Someone please investigate, because it is that clause that brought in fundamental change in the operations of PPB and the overall management of the pharmaceutical sector. We have a Board that we elect representatives but have no control at all in its running. PSK elects/nominates 4 people for three years who absolutely have no control on what they were nominated to do.
The learning curve for pharmacists end with them being declared BPharm graduates.
There are no serious tutors who force pharmacist interns to put what they learnt in school (if any) into practice, worsening the already fragile situation. We do not have predecessors worth mentioning; the serious pharmacists are almost all under 35 and with less than 10yrs of experience and hardly possess anything much more than the first degree. Kenya is almost devoid of specialist pharmacists.
If we delinked PPB from the parent ministry, make it an Authority and give the Board the power to hire and fire its employees, there will be fundamental changes in Kenya pharmaceutical sector. The Board should not be staffed by the Ministry of Health employees, they should all be sent out to carry out service delivery. If I'm not competent to discharge regualtory functions with my current training and expereince, which I rank to be in the top quartile among the Kenyan pharmacists, no one in that Board has. Tell me one you believe is and I will give you a reward. Most of them are entry level pharmacists or even interns-what do they know? Regulatory activity is not about filling forms and dusting files and drinking tea, no. It is a well thought out process from an experienced specialist pharmacists who shoul dbe issuing weekly or monthly bulletins to be circulated to all stakeholders.
The Board members and the technical staff must have post graduate qualifications and have more than 10 years experience post registration, in all the represented areas in the Board's mandate unless they are secretaries (like the one who's upstairs and has issues in the upstairs) or accountants or sweepers or messengers or drivers or guards. The CEO must be selected in a competitive process. He must not be the sitting Chief Pharmacist. He must possess postgraduate qualifications in pharmacy as well as an advanced management degree because the Board draws a huge budget. He (and that also stands for she) must have excellent presentation skills and must have made significant contributions in the relevant publications. He must be compensated well and must not serve for more than two terms of four years each. He may serve in an advisory role for another four years if he successfully completes two-four year terms. Its only such a Board that can confirm or rubbish any drug claims and we listen.
As for now I will only trust my own independent research.
Without that, the DMS or the PS or the Minister or even the President can comment on the cough syrups. As things are now, they are all more competent than that Board, I'm sorry to say that.
Vacation
The blogger apologizes to all esteemed readers for non-publishing of your favourite blog so many months after the lapse of the two weeks 'vacation' period. I'm happy to inform you that the long standing legal issues that made it difficult to publish your favourite blog have been solved.
Post your comments on how your favourite blog can be improved.
Post your comments on how your favourite blog can be improved.
Saturday, October 25, 2008
Vacation
timkopus blogs take a two weeks break. The blogger deeply regrets for the inconvenience this has caused to his ardent readers. The blogger promises even more relevant, practical, well researched and informative content for readers consumption and discussion in the subsequent posts. The blogger also wishes to inform the readers that there are four blogs running concurrently and they can all be accessed by viewing the blogger's profile. All blogs posts will resume on monday, November 3 2008. Finally, the blogger wishes to thank the readers for the invaluable comments that have proved once more the relevance of the blogs.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Pharmacy solutions
Check out a new series of posts under the name "pharmacy solutions".
Trust me. There is no single person who can come up with solutions to our well known but difficult to solve problems.
Check out every few days or weeks for new ideas in this interactive blog for home made solutions. Ideas straight from Kenyan pharmacists or those that have had first hand working experience in Kenya.
Regular readers will receive automatic notifications whenever there is a new comment.
So do you want to make the big move. Visit http://timkopussolutions.blogspot.com/ and make you ideas known to Kenya and the world.
Trust me. There is no single person who can come up with solutions to our well known but difficult to solve problems.
Check out every few days or weeks for new ideas in this interactive blog for home made solutions. Ideas straight from Kenyan pharmacists or those that have had first hand working experience in Kenya.
Regular readers will receive automatic notifications whenever there is a new comment.
So do you want to make the big move. Visit http://timkopussolutions.blogspot.com/ and make you ideas known to Kenya and the world.
Friday, October 10, 2008
Your comments on our Pharmacy and Poisons Board!
This is one institution that we cannot ignore. It controls all the facets of a pharmacist's professional life. Here is your chance to give your honest comment if it was not exactly close to the standard ones that are part of today's poll.
You can even take advantage of this to speak your mind about this institution we loathe so much, yet we still need just as much.
You can even take advantage of this to speak your mind about this institution we loathe so much, yet we still need just as much.
Sunday, October 5, 2008
Stormy PSK meeting on PPB nominations
Back in August 20 at around 7pm, there was a meeting that I’m sure many pharmacists were aware of but probably did not consider it very important. It was PSK election meeting of the nominees to the Pharmacy and Poisons Board (PPB). Well, I’m sure those who did not attend might want to know what became of it, and for those who attended, they may find out that the official minutes of the meeting may give an inadequate account of the happenings on that floor. The first two or the only two candidates according to the law were to be nominated and be presented to the minister for appointment. The minister then picks one of the two nominees for each of the four different practice areas of pharmacy and that decision will be gazetted. The minister’s decision will then be final.
Armed with this information, I headed for KICC, was it Aberdares Hall, to vote and follow the proceedings. I was there not so much as a PSK member but as a person who was really trying to know what it was all about. My ballot paper didn’t have much to show for growth if any in the right direction. The same old folks with a mix of new blood here and there were fighting for positions for or for not a little more than the perks and priviledges that come with it. There was a sprinkling of one or two youngsters, who apart from being young(er) pretty had the same generic visions for pharmacy in Kenya for the next three years. In total there were 13 contestants for the four board positions allowed for PSK members. This was one full house and I could sense mixed feelings in the room; those ones of hope, anticipation, resentment as well as curiosity.
One man called Wanjala was not particularly happy today. No one, I noticed, allows him to speak so he forces his words through when he wants to rather allow the chairman to give him to go ahead. He rightfully knows that the chairman will never allowed him to talk, just as he would not have allowed him to write him the letter he wrote him and informed the other PSK members of the letter’s contents via email, if he had the power to. Wanjala definitely knows something but he was obviously outnumbered by the old folks who seemed to have ganged against him, and successfully so. One even alleged that he was attending the meeting illegally because he was not a paid up PSK member at that time. The plot worked because man Wanjala was being forced to defend himself rather than explain more to us why he thinks that the elections were flawed and should be declared by the returning officer null and void. He wanted to produce PSK payment receipt as evidence of him paying his subscription, but then the returning officer himself disowned him. The returning officer added in that he received a memorandum that was not signed, for ownership purposes and so his objection was the only thing that was null and void that evening. The only way that election would have been halted seemed to be by this Wanjala man hiring an independent lawyer, and not the society lawyer who gets some pocket change for running PSK elections, an activity that does not require much of his input, but just his rubber stamp.
But before that there was a small talk from some hirelings of PSK, oops GSK, targeted at marketing a human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine. GSK, PSK, what a rhyme? Some city gynaecologist who claims to charge 2000KSh for Pap smear took us through the 200 strains of HPV, a DNA virus, where 15 are known to be high risk. But then the vaccine is available for only two strains, type 16 and 18, the ones that are thought to be the most common, most virulent and most etc. You know most is a very non committal term, a very good thing for anything that is medical school. He had been preceded by a gentleman who I suspect sponsored whatever was to be sponsored in the meeting; the process of the elections may be. I’m informed that elections are nowadays very expensive affairs, not with the printing of secure ballot papers, hiring and paying a returning officer who would rather make his money in commissions of inquiry, and domestic observations of the (il)legality of the process with a view to make some objectionable comments that may require the re-reading of the constitution.
Anyway, I was talking about the ‘CPD’ that was being offered to half or fully asleep audience, most of whom are in their fifty’s or may be older. The rule seems to be the young do not need or want these CPDs while the old sleep through the ‘CPDs’ they really need to renew their annual practice licenses for their businesses. I really doubt a Dominic needs it because I do not think he even has time to practice in his private pharmacy, and the CPDs were not designed for the spouses of pharmacists who seem to be really interested in the workings of a pharmacy. Well, this PSK, no GSK guy managed to add into the very long list of product names in my head a Cervarix®, this 200 bob , no, 1200 bob, no, 4500 bob, no, 7000 bob vaccine. Some wazees were momentarily awoken from their sleep by that part of the talk with some questions related to the mark up. Our marketer today was interested in rubbing this name into our heads more than its price, or may be the price depended on the client pharmacy they will sell their vaccines to. So this was brushed off, and one or two or slightly more pharmacists tried to revisit where sun did not shine during the presentations. A Dr Menge was more interested in the vaccine as a potential toxin, reinforcing the idea that what one thinks is what they are. He also was involved in a PCR brawl where both the presenter and he were struggling to say it is an antigen test using different words. Well, that was resolved, one of them decided to surrender.
Well the presentations were over, and people had earned their CPDs for their practice licenses (not themselves) but the vote counting was still going on. Dr Wanyanga took us through screensaver questions that were more of ‘just for the laughs’ than they were for the topic of discussion. Issues like possible mass male vaccination to prevent the spread of HPV to women and cause cervical cancers were discussed. More relevant issues like the vaccines potential to be used for prophylactic or therapeutic purposes during the early stages of the infection were also discussed. Anyway there were many volunteers (or casuals) who did the ballot papers separation and counting. The room rapidly became empty during Dr Wanyanga’s comical exploits of the topic, which made me conclude that all these people were either here for the CPD points or they were genuinely not interested in the outcome of the elections. Our Dominic aka Ngugi decided to withdraw anyway from the race as a community pharmacy representative but allowed his votes to be counted anyway.
With one down and 13 left, lawyer Mwenesi; our returning officer finally announced the polling results, amidst loud objections by Wanjala and quiet objections by Wanjala’s fans, and it was as follows:
Community Pharmacy
• Anthony Walela 146 (Nominee)
• Muhu Kahiga 24 (Nominee)
• Dominic Karanja (veteran) 54 (withdrew)
• Kijana Baya (veteran) 24
Public Sector Pharmacy
• Wanjau Mbuthia 88 (Nominee)
• Micah Anyona 77 (Nominee)
• Jennifer Orwa 73
This was one close race, too bad there was no female nominee in this category just like in the first.
Industrial Pharmacy
• Ann Maina 97 (Nominee)
• W. Kimatu 86 (Nominee)
• Anastacia Nyalita (veteran) 70
• Larry M. Kimani 43
Hospital Pharmacy
• D. B. Menge 282 (Nominee)
• Bildah Kiama Murage 62 (Nominee)
Bildah was voted for in the wrong category (public sector) giving Menge much more votes than he needed to win the election. The error was corrected during the announcing of the results.
Now the minister of medical services is allowed to pick any of the two nominees to the board. The nominees names will be passed on to him, without the vote tally of course as that will be considered by him to be forcing him to pick predetermined people. The meeting was hurriedly adjourned, lest someone will raise a point of order that may not be readily welcomed by the officials.
Armed with this information, I headed for KICC, was it Aberdares Hall, to vote and follow the proceedings. I was there not so much as a PSK member but as a person who was really trying to know what it was all about. My ballot paper didn’t have much to show for growth if any in the right direction. The same old folks with a mix of new blood here and there were fighting for positions for or for not a little more than the perks and priviledges that come with it. There was a sprinkling of one or two youngsters, who apart from being young(er) pretty had the same generic visions for pharmacy in Kenya for the next three years. In total there were 13 contestants for the four board positions allowed for PSK members. This was one full house and I could sense mixed feelings in the room; those ones of hope, anticipation, resentment as well as curiosity.
One man called Wanjala was not particularly happy today. No one, I noticed, allows him to speak so he forces his words through when he wants to rather allow the chairman to give him to go ahead. He rightfully knows that the chairman will never allowed him to talk, just as he would not have allowed him to write him the letter he wrote him and informed the other PSK members of the letter’s contents via email, if he had the power to. Wanjala definitely knows something but he was obviously outnumbered by the old folks who seemed to have ganged against him, and successfully so. One even alleged that he was attending the meeting illegally because he was not a paid up PSK member at that time. The plot worked because man Wanjala was being forced to defend himself rather than explain more to us why he thinks that the elections were flawed and should be declared by the returning officer null and void. He wanted to produce PSK payment receipt as evidence of him paying his subscription, but then the returning officer himself disowned him. The returning officer added in that he received a memorandum that was not signed, for ownership purposes and so his objection was the only thing that was null and void that evening. The only way that election would have been halted seemed to be by this Wanjala man hiring an independent lawyer, and not the society lawyer who gets some pocket change for running PSK elections, an activity that does not require much of his input, but just his rubber stamp.
But before that there was a small talk from some hirelings of PSK, oops GSK, targeted at marketing a human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine. GSK, PSK, what a rhyme? Some city gynaecologist who claims to charge 2000KSh for Pap smear took us through the 200 strains of HPV, a DNA virus, where 15 are known to be high risk. But then the vaccine is available for only two strains, type 16 and 18, the ones that are thought to be the most common, most virulent and most etc. You know most is a very non committal term, a very good thing for anything that is medical school. He had been preceded by a gentleman who I suspect sponsored whatever was to be sponsored in the meeting; the process of the elections may be. I’m informed that elections are nowadays very expensive affairs, not with the printing of secure ballot papers, hiring and paying a returning officer who would rather make his money in commissions of inquiry, and domestic observations of the (il)legality of the process with a view to make some objectionable comments that may require the re-reading of the constitution.
Anyway, I was talking about the ‘CPD’ that was being offered to half or fully asleep audience, most of whom are in their fifty’s or may be older. The rule seems to be the young do not need or want these CPDs while the old sleep through the ‘CPDs’ they really need to renew their annual practice licenses for their businesses. I really doubt a Dominic needs it because I do not think he even has time to practice in his private pharmacy, and the CPDs were not designed for the spouses of pharmacists who seem to be really interested in the workings of a pharmacy. Well, this PSK, no GSK guy managed to add into the very long list of product names in my head a Cervarix®, this 200 bob , no, 1200 bob, no, 4500 bob, no, 7000 bob vaccine. Some wazees were momentarily awoken from their sleep by that part of the talk with some questions related to the mark up. Our marketer today was interested in rubbing this name into our heads more than its price, or may be the price depended on the client pharmacy they will sell their vaccines to. So this was brushed off, and one or two or slightly more pharmacists tried to revisit where sun did not shine during the presentations. A Dr Menge was more interested in the vaccine as a potential toxin, reinforcing the idea that what one thinks is what they are. He also was involved in a PCR brawl where both the presenter and he were struggling to say it is an antigen test using different words. Well, that was resolved, one of them decided to surrender.
Well the presentations were over, and people had earned their CPDs for their practice licenses (not themselves) but the vote counting was still going on. Dr Wanyanga took us through screensaver questions that were more of ‘just for the laughs’ than they were for the topic of discussion. Issues like possible mass male vaccination to prevent the spread of HPV to women and cause cervical cancers were discussed. More relevant issues like the vaccines potential to be used for prophylactic or therapeutic purposes during the early stages of the infection were also discussed. Anyway there were many volunteers (or casuals) who did the ballot papers separation and counting. The room rapidly became empty during Dr Wanyanga’s comical exploits of the topic, which made me conclude that all these people were either here for the CPD points or they were genuinely not interested in the outcome of the elections. Our Dominic aka Ngugi decided to withdraw anyway from the race as a community pharmacy representative but allowed his votes to be counted anyway.
With one down and 13 left, lawyer Mwenesi; our returning officer finally announced the polling results, amidst loud objections by Wanjala and quiet objections by Wanjala’s fans, and it was as follows:
Community Pharmacy
• Anthony Walela 146 (Nominee)
• Muhu Kahiga 24 (Nominee)
• Dominic Karanja (veteran) 54 (withdrew)
• Kijana Baya (veteran) 24
Public Sector Pharmacy
• Wanjau Mbuthia 88 (Nominee)
• Micah Anyona 77 (Nominee)
• Jennifer Orwa 73
This was one close race, too bad there was no female nominee in this category just like in the first.
Industrial Pharmacy
• Ann Maina 97 (Nominee)
• W. Kimatu 86 (Nominee)
• Anastacia Nyalita (veteran) 70
• Larry M. Kimani 43
Hospital Pharmacy
• D. B. Menge 282 (Nominee)
• Bildah Kiama Murage 62 (Nominee)
Bildah was voted for in the wrong category (public sector) giving Menge much more votes than he needed to win the election. The error was corrected during the announcing of the results.
Now the minister of medical services is allowed to pick any of the two nominees to the board. The nominees names will be passed on to him, without the vote tally of course as that will be considered by him to be forcing him to pick predetermined people. The meeting was hurriedly adjourned, lest someone will raise a point of order that may not be readily welcomed by the officials.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
Your comments on our Pharmacy and Poisons Board!
This is one institution that we cannot ignore. It controls all the facets of a pharmacist's professional life. Here is your chance to give your honest comment if it was not exactly close to the standard ones that are part of today's poll.
You can even take advantage of this to speak your mind about this institution we loathe so much, yet we still need just as much.
You can even take advantage of this to speak your mind about this institution we loathe so much, yet we still need just as much.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)